Source: Unsplash.com
Whether you are just starting out in trading or you have been in the game for a while, you have probably asked yourself this: Should I go solo or join a prop firm? On one side, there’s the freedom and full control of independent trading. On the other, you have large funded accounts offered by a prop firm. Which path is better? Let’s break it down.
What Is Independent Trading?
Independent trading is what most people start with. You open a brokerage account, fund it with your own money, and start trading. You get to call the shots, manage the risk, and deal with the wins and the losses. It’s fully in your control, and that’s both its biggest pro and con.
What is a Prop Firm?
A proprietary trading firm, or prop firm for short, lets you trade using their capital. In return, they take a part of the profits that you make. Many firms ask traders to pass an evaluation or challenge first to prove that they can trade responsibly, but an instant funding prop firm allows you to get funded almost immediately, instead of grinding through a test.
Capital Access
With independent trading, you’re limited to your own account. For instance, if you start with $500, that’s all you’ve got. Prop firms, on the other hand, give you thousands in trading capital – or even more. This lets you scale your trades and potentially make higher returns without risking your own bank account. The clear winner here is prop trading. More capital gives you more opportunity and less personal risk.
Risk Exposure
With independent trading, every loss drains your personal money. One bad day can even wipe out your entire savings. Prop firms come with rules and drawdown limits, and the loss doesn’t come out of your pocket. Again, prop firms give you a better opportunity.
Freedom and Flexibility
Independent trading gives you total freedom. You can trade any strategy, any time, with any pair. There are no rules except your own. Prop firms have restrictions and policies that you need to follow. If you don’t, you lose access and get kicked out.
Profit Share
You get to keep all of your profits with independent trading. No one takes a cut. Most prop firms offer a 70% to 90% split. This means that you don’t get to keep everything you make. But you’re earning on someone else’s capital, so it evens out.
Cost of Entry
You can start small with independent trading, but you need at least a few hundreds to make decent trades. And even that comes with risk. Prop firms give you accounts with bigger funds, but you need to either pass a challenge first or pay an entry fee. Still, it’s way more affordable than the former.
Conclusion
The path you choose depends on your trading style, goals, and risk tolerance. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But with the rise of instant funding, more traders are choosing the prop firm route. Whichever path you take, just make sure that you’re trading smart and following rules – whether they are the firm’s or your personal ones.
Refresh Date: August 21, 2025
